field notes Jonas

The vocal my own widener sank

I put six loops through WIDE and folded them to mono. Four were fine, two were not, and you can check your own tracks for the same thing in two minutes.

I’ve been taking WIDE apart for the big update, and yesterday I pulled six loops out of my sample library, ran them through the WIDE you have now, folded the result to mono and looked at what was left.

Four of them were fine. A guitar, a synth line, a bass and a drum loop all lost less than half a dB against their own stereo version, which nobody is going to hear.

Then there was a vocal loop and a piano. With four of my six M/S presets they came out between 2.3 and 3.5 dB quieter in mono, even though the stereo level hadn’t changed at all. With everything turned all the way up it was about 8 dB (you wouldn’t run it like that, but still).

What those two have in common is that they were already wide before WIDE got to them. A widener like this turns up the sides, and the sides are the part that cancels when left and right get added together, so a track that is mostly sides to begin with doesn’t have much in the middle to hold it up. The guitar had plenty of middle and the vocal had a lot less.

Try this

You can check your own tracks for this in about two minutes, and it works with any widener. You need a correlation meter (the one that goes from -1 to +1). Some DAWs have one, and if yours doesn’t, CHECK has one and it’s free.

Put it on the track before the widener and play the busiest part. My guitar and synth sat up around +0.9, and those were the ones that took the widening without complaining. The vocal sat at +0.3 and the piano at +0.2, so if you see a number down there I would leave that track alone and go widen something else.

If you widen it anyway, keep an eye on the meter afterwards, because the two loops that lost level were also the two that ended up below zero. And press the mono button once before you bounce. It takes three seconds and it would have caught both of mine.

From the studio

So yes, that was my own plugin, and four of the six M/S presets in it do this to material that is already wide. I’d rather you hear it from me than from a phone speaker.

I’m working on a version that holds the sides back when a track is about to go under. It has the same rule as everything else in this update, which is that it has to beat the WIDE you already have in a blind test or it doesn’t ship.

The update itself comes in two rounds, the fixes first and the new things a bit later.

P.S. If you try the meter on one of your own mixes, hit reply and tell me which track turned out to be the widest.

more field notes